The Capitalist Atlas

Starbucks' Union Fight Reached the Senate. Then Came the Profit Question.

November 18, 2026 · Starbucks · Howard Schultz · Labor

On March 29, 2023, nine days after handing the CEO job to Laxman Narasimhan, Howard Schultz testified before the Senate HELP Committee about Starbucks’ response to a wave of union votes at its stores.

The labor question

Chair Bernie Sanders said that baristas in nearly 300 union stores were still waiting for a first contract, and asked whether Schultz would read a notice an administrative law judge had ordered about workers’ rights.

“No, I am not, because Starbucks Coffee Company did not break the law.”

Starbucks has contested the labor-board rulings against it. The union says the company has stalled bargaining; the company says it has tried to schedule hundreds of sessions.

The business question

Sen. Mitt Romney asked where Starbucks’ profits go: to executives, dividends or buybacks? Schultz said most of it went back into the business, “roasting plants, $800,000 to a million dollars to build a store,” and that he had paused buybacks on his return in 2022 to fund higher wages.

What happened next

  • Brian Niccol became CEO in September 2024.
  • Workers United started an open-ended strike in November 2025. Talks resumed in April 2026, with each side accusing the other of moving backward. As of this writing, there is no first contract.
  • Sales reached $37.9 billion in fiscal 2026, but operating margin fell from 16.3% in fiscal 2023 to 9.7%, as the company paid for a turnaround and restructured its China business.

The Capitalist Atlas take

An unresolved labor dispute is a cost line, whichever side you think is right. It shows up in margins, in shareholder votes and in how customers see the brand, long after the hearing ends.


Go deeper

As an Amazon Associate, The Capitalist Atlas earns from qualifying purchases.

Footage: U.S. Senate HELP Committee, public record. This article is commentary and analysis, not financial advice.

Source: U.S. Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions, hearing of March 29, 2023 (public record)

More Breakdowns

All of Breakdowns