The Capitalist Atlas

Elon Musk, Part 1: Fired as CEO, Still Made $176 Million

October 27, 2026 · Titans of Capital · Elon Musk · PayPal

Elon Musk, Part 1: Fired as CEO, Still Made $176 Million, slide 1 of 7Elon Musk, Part 1: Fired as CEO, Still Made $176 Million, slide 2 of 7Elon Musk, Part 1: Fired as CEO, Still Made $176 Million, slide 3 of 7Elon Musk, Part 1: Fired as CEO, Still Made $176 Million, slide 4 of 7Elon Musk, Part 1: Fired as CEO, Still Made $176 Million, slide 5 of 7Elon Musk, Part 1: Fired as CEO, Still Made $176 Million, slide 6 of 7Elon Musk, Part 1: Fired as CEO, Still Made $176 Million, slide 7 of 7

Before rockets and electric cars, Elon Musk’s biggest win came from a company where he lost the top job. This is Part 1 of his story: how a $22 million payout became a $176 million one, and the stake that funded everything that came next.

1999 · The stake: recycle the win

In February 1999, Compaq bought Musk’s first startup, the online city-guide company Zip2, for $307 million in cash. Musk owned about 7%, which came to $22 million. He was 27.

1999 · The bet: bet the winnings

A month later he put $12 million, more than half of it, into co-founding X.com, an internet bank. It launched in December 1999 with no fees and no overdraft penalties, at a time when most people still didn’t trust a bank they couldn’t walk into.

1999 · The growth: buy the network

X.com paid people to join: a $20 card for signing up and $10 for each friend referred. More than 200,000 people signed up in the first two months. Paying for every new customer was expensive, but it built a network fast, and in payments the network is the product.

2000 · The ouster: keep your stake

X.com’s biggest rival was Confinity, a startup run by Peter Thiel and Max Levchin whose product, PayPal, let people send money by email. In March 2000 the two companies merged. Musk soon became CEO, but the merged teams disagreed over direction: Musk kept pushing X.com while most others favored PayPal.

In September 2000, while Musk was flying abroad on a trip that doubled as his honeymoon, the board replaced him with Peter Thiel. Musk stayed on the board and chose not to fight the decision. Most importantly, he kept his shares.

2002 · The payoff: ownership beats titles

The company, now called PayPal, went public in February 2002 at $13 a share. In July, eBay agreed to buy it for $1.5 billion in stock, and the deal closed that October. Musk was PayPal’s largest shareholder at 11.7%, and his take was about $176 million.

The takeaway

Musk lost the title but kept the equity, and the equity is what got paid. He then put most of that money into the riskiest bets of his life.

Your turn: would you have bet your $176 million on rockets?

Part 2 drops Tuesday, November 17: SpaceX, $100 million of his own money, and three failed launches in a row. Follow @capitalistatlas so you don’t miss it, or see every chapter on the Titans of Capital page.


Sources

  • Wikipedia, “Business career of Elon Musk”: Compaq bought Zip2 for $307M in cash (Feb. 1999), Musk’s $22M for 7%, $12M into X.com, eBay’s $1.5B stock deal, Musk’s 11.7% and $176M, $100M into SpaceX
  • Wikipedia, “X.com (bank)”: launch Dec. 1999, no fees, $20/$10 bonuses, 200,000+ sign-ups in two months, Confinity merger, September 2000 board vote during his honeymoon
  • Wikipedia, “Timeline of PayPal”: merger announced March 2, 2000; IPO Feb. 15, 2002 at $13; eBay deal announced July 8, closed October 2002
  • Snopes, “Was Elon Musk Fired from PayPal?”: the board’s no-confidence move while he was flying, replacement by Thiel, Musk’s decision not to fight it

The Atlas reading list

As an Amazon Associate, The Capitalist Atlas earns from qualifying purchases.

This article is historical commentary, not investment advice.

Source: Wikipedia (Business career of Elon Musk, X.com, Timeline of PayPal) and Snopes; full links below. Facts checked Oct 18, 2026.

More Titans of Capital

All of Titans of Capital